"It's my opinion that if a pregnant woman is going to make one organic choice, that choice should be milk products."
—
Barbara Kingsolver, author, organophile and mom
**********************************************************************************
Non-pregnant women and men, don't think that counts you out from reading the rest of this post.
In the wake of the ongoing
organic milk shortage, I thought it would be appropriate to address why, now more than ever, it's important to maintain this staple as the one organic item you adhere to if that's as far as you're willing to go. Just in case you've been living under a rock, buying USDA-certified organic milk means that you're buying a product that is free of synthetic growth hormones, pesticides and antibiotics. This is explained on the
USDA website, in
books written by authors I trust and is oftentimes even clearly spelled out right on the front of the milk jug or carton you pick up at your local supermarket. So what, you might ask, is the big deal with growth hormones, pesticides and antibiotics? Man. Got a few hours?
I'll try to give you the long and short of it without rewriting the entire transcript of the movie
Food Inc (which, by the way, if you haven't seen, you most definitely ARE living under a rock, in which case I wouldn't expect you to have a television, DVD player or the internet,
all places where you can watch this shocking documentary that would probably be burned into your brain immediately after watching otherwise. Lucky you). Let's just try to break it down one by one, shall we?
- Synthetic growth hormones
Although it may not need much explanation if you're able to read this blog and thus understand and comprehend the ins and outs of the English language, a synthetic growth hormone is exactly what it sounds like: A synthetic (not natural; made-made) hormone, or a chemical in the body that sends out signals to other cells and chemicals in your body, affecting endocrine functions and, in this case, milk production in cows. Putting two and two together, you should be grasping the fact that factory farmers use rGBH, the cow growth hormone, in simple terms to make the cows produce more milk. Faster. Bigger. Better. More. Sounds great, right? Well, turns out it may not be so great for your health, because milk from rGBH-treated cows contains higher levels of insulin growth factor-1, an important protein in the bodies of both children and adults. Higher levels of this protein have been
linked to breast cancer and colon cancer. Need I say more? I can, if you want. Really. I could go on for hours.
While this is a huge group of substances intended to prevent, destroy or repel pests of many kinds, from that trusty old can of Raid under your sink (ew, cockroaches) to what factory farmers use to spray their once-delicious peaches and strawberries, in the case of milk, you might be thinking Wait — isn't part of this whole problem the fact that cows are fed corn and grain instead of grazing on grass? (If you know anything about anything, of course.) Well, you're right. According to a report from
The Organic Center, an organization dedicated to the conversion of agriculture to organic methods based on science, health and environmental benefits, DPA, a high-volume industrial chemical found in 98% of conventional milk samples, is most likely taken up through drugs administered to the animals (see below), rubber and/or plastic products used in factory farms or ingredients used in milk cartons and other types of conventional packaging. However it gets in there I don't really care — it's in there, among other pesticides, and in their totality the pesticides found in milk can contain more
carcinogens, developmental or reproductive toxins, more suspected hormone disruptors and neurotoxins. Now I'm no scientist, but none of that sounds delicious and wholesome to me.
Without sounding completely condescending and mean, no, honey, not all antibiotics are good things. And in your milk? Ha. Think about it this way: Do you take amoxicillin or penicillin every time you get a runny nose? Do you go to the doctor for every single cold and virus you get, and is your MD actually willing to prescribe you something at each visit (other than pushing chicken soup and fluids)? Then why would you want to drink drugs every time you throw back a glass of milk with your cookie, pour it on your cereal or, hello, drink your daily grande latte? I'll tell you why, and in part it's the same reason why your doc is so hesitant to pump you full of pills each time: for one, antibiotics in milk could cause bacteria resistant to the same antibiotics she prescribes when you do actually need something for an infection. In addition, exposure to unnecessary antibiotics could cause the development of
new allergies, or reactions in people who already suffer from allergies (like me). Does anything about this sound appealing?
I know what some of you are thinking — organic milk is more expensive; I can't afford it; I can't even find it on store shelves any more; why bother. Well, if you're not convinced after reading my little speech, fine. Google "organic milk versus regular milk," read the
New York Times, ask a friend, order some educational materials off of Amazon. Whatever you choose to do, don't just make excuses to ignore the issue. And might I add, there are plenty of small-farm operations that sell milk in stores or deliver it to your door that may not be organically certified but are probably better than factory operations and even some "organic factory farms." If you're at all interested in the issue, do your research and pick a milk that you feel good about drinking. Factor in how the animals are treated, what they eat, if they're allowed to pasture when the weather permits and, if you can get anyone to tell you, what the somatic cell count is in the product (this is an indicator of the quality in terms of how it relates to bacteria and pathogens found in the cows). At the time of posting, only
Organic Valley and
Oberweis (a small local dairy, although not USDA certified organic) provided any information on this number in particular, even after multiple attempts to contact people at both small farms and larger organic companies. Not exactly confidence boosting, but I'm allergic to soy, I don't like the taste of almond or rice milk and thus far I still believe in the health benefits of drinking milk from well-cared-for cows.
Wherever this discussion leads you, keep in mind that it's not all about you. I don't know about your kid, but mine guzzles milk like there's no tomorrow, and his health is kind of majorly important to me. I also don't like the footage I've seen of the poor cows on huge factory farms, and by now we should all know that synthetic pesticides are no good no matter which way you see the issue. So if the only thing still standing in your way is the cost difference (I for one have had no problem getting local or organic milk during this supposed "shortage") — which can be anywhere from one to four dollars a gallon, I know — why don't you leave that box of crackers on the shelf and put the money toward your health? (Or the ice cream, or the donuts, or the frozen pizza — maybe not everything, but ONE THING?) I know, I know — now that I've said it, the rebel in you is going to fill your cart with all that junk and, just to spite me, a jug of regular milk. Fine — it's your decision, and it comes down to what you believe. I'm happy even if just one conventional milk-drinker tries organic "just in case" or "when I can"; I've done my part — for today.
Next up: Spend on Milk, Save on...Bleach?